PARAJE, N.M. — On the annual Feast Day in the Laguna Pueblo village, Ashley Sarracino was busy preparing her family for celebrations. She deftly dressed her niece in a traditional black cotton manta, tying a sash around her waist while balancing clothespins in her mouth. As an experienced member of the community and a former pueblo council representative, she managed the dual roles of caretaker and leader.
Despite former U.S. Interior Secretary Deb Haaland approaching her historic goal of becoming the first Native American woman governor, women in Laguna Pueblo face challenges in pursuing leadership roles. Sarracino noted that she was removed from the council after alleging gender-based pay disparity, a claim that pueblo officials deny.
In New Mexico’s pueblos, including Laguna, women are often restricted from holding top government positions due to tribal laws and customs. Haaland shared her own experiences with the Associated Press, reflecting on her nomination to her pueblo council, where she did not advance past a primary election. “It’s still a man’s world in a lot of pueblo communities, and certainly in mine,” she said.
Pay disparity became a fight over women’s roles
Hoping to serve their communities after gaining education off the reservation is a common path for many young Native people. Sarracino has built a career in nonprofit work and political organizing, even chairing her county’s Democratic Party. In 2022, she was nominated for council secretary and won the position after finishing second in voting.
Upon reviewing budget documents, Sarracino discovered a significant pay gap: she earned $14,000 less than her male predecessor. After seeking clarification from the pueblo governor, a dispute erupted that ultimately led to her removal from the council. The council maintains her pay was lower due to her lack of experience and claims she abandoned her position. However, Sarracino feels her dismissal reflects longstanding sexist attitudes, pointing out that while women can run for certain council positions, the roles of governor and lieutenant governor remain off-limits.
Her challenge has not only drained her spirit but also ended up in tribal court, which dismissed her case this year on sovereign immunity grounds. Observing Haaland make strides in politics has been bittersweet for her. “We all know she would never have the same opportunity here,” Sarracino added.
Nevertheless, there are indications of change. Emily Hunt, a trailblazing female elected official from Laguna Pueblo, expressed hope that the community will eventually nominate a female governor, though she is uncertain if she will witness this change in her lifetime.
Pueblo governance is varied and complex
Governance structures differ across pueblos, with many retaining traditional theocratic systems where men hold positions appointed by ceremonial elders. Charlotte Little, a representative from San Felipe Pueblo, emphasized the importance of respecting cultural roots rather than pursuing leadership roles at home.
In contrast, some pueblos adopted secular constitutions due to federal pressure in the 1930s, including Isleta Pueblo, which saw Verna Teller become its first woman governor in 1986, despite initial resistance. Now in her 70s, Teller attributes the ongoing challenges women face in governance to historical colonial influences.
However, not all pueblos restrict women in governance. Pojoaque Pueblo allows open candidacy, and since 2021, women have filled all four executive positions.
Planning with the next generation in mind
Haaland is among several pueblo women experiencing success in broader political roles. She has encouraged others to seek opportunities beyond their communities, stating, “We need more Native women everywhere.”
Sarracino has left the door open for a potential future run for the pueblo council. Following Haaland’s election night celebration, she is considering a path in state politics. As she hosted family and friends on Feast Day, Sarracino remained focused on the next generation, ensuring her nieces left the gathering with treats and laughter.
“That’s the reason I couldn’t just let it go,” she explained. “Because I know they’re coming up behind me.”


