In a recent mock draft for the 2027 fantasy baseball season, the first round revealed a notable lack of consensus among participants regarding player selections. The draft featured prominent fantasy analysts including John Sharples, Scott White from CBS Sports, and others.
The first pick went to John Sharples, who chose Shohei Ohtani, despite early indications that Pete Crow-Armstrong might be the favored selection. Crow-Armstrong was picked second by White, followed by Aaron Judge at third, showing the varying opinions on top players. This variance is attributed largely to many established stars’ performance dips in the previous season.
Scott White expressed a particular interest in Ohtani, noting that while he wasn’t as healthy in 2026 and did not hit his typical .300 average with 50 home runs and 20 steals, he believes Ohtani’s recovery is more feasible than Crow-Armstrong maintaining his breakout season. White’s drafted top three, consisting of Ohtani, Crow-Armstrong, and Judge, reflects his personal rankings amid differing average draft positions (ADP) from NFBC.
A surprising exclusion from the first round was James Wood, who White suggested deserved to be a top-six pick. Wood’s previous performance before an oblique strain in August had positioned him as a contender among the elite selections.
Yordan Alvarez was selected ninth, which contrasted his ADP of twelfth, while Junior Caminero, drafted tenth, does not align with White’s fourth-place ranking for Alvarez, illustrating a significant disparity in expected value among these athletes.
As the draft continued, White noted a clear drop in talent in the second round, particularly with players who had let down their teams in 2026, such as Ronald Acuna Jr., Jose Ramirez, Corbin Carroll, and Julio Rodriguez. Many of these selections raised concerns about their potential to rebound.
Reflecting on his own team build, White revealed his satisfaction with the draft, particularly his strategic selections in the early rounds that prioritized position scarcity. He drew attention to his choices in the middle rounds, highlighting picks like Jake McCarthy and Freddie Freeman for bolstering batting averages, a category he earlier neglected.
The mock draft signals an interesting offseason ahead for fantasy baseball enthusiasts, as values for various players evolve. Expert opinions and ambiguous early-round choices will likely continue to provoke vigorous debate leading up to the actual drafting seasons.

