The notion of “man flu”—the idea that men suffer more than women when ill—may be rooted in biological differences, according to new research from McMaster University. The study indicates that biological sex can influence disease severity in acute viral infections.
Published in The Journal of Infectious Diseases, the research involved male and female mice infected with the Zika virus. The findings reveal that male mice experienced more severe clinical symptoms compared to females, despite having similar viral loads.
Examining Gender Differences in Viral Infections
Previous studies have noted that males tend to experience worse outcomes in various viral infections, a trend reflected during the COVID-19 pandemic, where a higher proportion of severe cases and mortality were observed in men. Similar patterns have been reported with the H7N9 influenza and West Nile virus.
Alexa Mansour, a PhD student at McMaster University and the study’s lead author, explained that the team initially focused on Zika virus symptoms without recognizing that their study involved only female mice. After introducing male mice, the characteristic neurological complications associated with the virus reappeared.
Understanding Zika Virus
The Zika virus is spread by mosquitoes and primarily found in tropical regions. Infection can cause mild symptoms but may lead to serious neurological issues such as Guillain-Barré syndrome and myelitis. Currently, there are no approved vaccines or treatments available for Zika virus disease.
Further analysis revealed that male mice were significantly more vulnerable to severe neurological effects, such as paralysis, whereas female mice mostly remained unaffected. Researchers also found that the viral loads in both sexes were comparable, raising questions about why males fared worse.
Professor Ali Ashkar, a lead investigator on the study, noted that all test subjects were genetically similar and infected under identical conditions, making the drastic differences in disease manifestation perplexing. This suggests that immune response differences between men and women may play a critical role in these outcomes.
The researchers propose that sex hormones could influence these immune responses, necessitating further examination. T cells, which are key components of the immune system, are likely involved in the disease dynamics observed in the study.
With evidence mounting that immune response variations contribute to male susceptibility to severe viral diseases, the researchers emphasize the importance of considering biological sex in infectious disease studies. They argue that acknowledging “man flu” as a legitimate biological difference could enhance clinical care.
“Physicians should manage inflammation early in male patients suffering from any acute viral infection,” Ashkar stated. He highlighted that existing effective anti-inflammatory medications should be utilized, though treatment plans might need to be tailored to acknowledge this higher susceptibility in men.


