Justice Department officials are seeking to prevent the potential deposition of former special counsel Jack Smith in a $10 billion defamation lawsuit filed by Donald Trump against the BBC. The lawsuit centers on the network’s editing of a clip from Trump’s remarks on January 6, 2021.
In a recent court filing, DOJ officials argued that Smith “is not at liberty to disclose” any information protected by grand jury secrecy rules and classified information privileges. They contend that, should the court allow Smith to testify, it should deny the BBC’s request for him to disclose details regarding testimonies from the grand jury. The department claims the BBC has not demonstrated the necessary conditions to access such confidential information in a separate legal proceeding.
This filing was submitted to Chief Judge James E. Boasberg in Washington. Additionally, DOJ officials requested that Boasberg transfer the case to the Southern District of Florida, where the BBC lawsuit is currently being adjudicated. According to the DOJ, Smith’s attorneys did not consent to this transfer but also did not plan to formally oppose it.
Upon receiving a subpoena related to the BBC lawsuit, Smith alerted the Justice Department and indicated he would not testify without authorization, as mandated by departmental regulations. On November 2, the DOJ informed Smith’s legal team that it would not grant permission for him to testify.
In the 29-page court filing, DOJ officials asserted that the BBC had failed to provide a “particularized need” for Smith’s testimony. They referenced a previous ruling in a related civil case, where testimony from former Trump White House aide Cassidy Hutchinson was deemed “largely irrelevant” to the lawsuit. The DOJ’s filing emphasized that Smith lacked any firsthand knowledge of the January 6 events, as he was serving as a war crimes prosecutor in The Hague during that time.
The DOJ argued, “If Ms. Hutchinson’s testimony is largely irrelevant to this lawsuit, then Mr. Smith’s testimony is even less relevant.” They pointed out that Hutchinson had direct experience on the date of the events, unlike Smith.
The filing further noted that Smith could only provide potentially outdated and second-hand accounts based on an investigation he oversaw years prior.
On the same day, a Florida judge allowed Trump to postpone his deposition in the defamation suit until late January. The delay was granted based on Trump’s assertion of “national importance,” raising concerns from the BBC, particularly since Trump attended a political rally instead of complying with the original timeline.
No additional depositions of BBC personnel will occur until Trump has been deposed. The BBC maintains that Trump has not been defamed and did not sustain any damages from their editing of his January 6 remarks.


